compiled by Eleanore & John Woollard
with Bob McKeon
We look back with amazement and joy over the past decade and a half of fulfilling interaction and dialogue between members of the Mennonite and Roman Catholic (RC) communities in Edmonton.
This journey together began in 2010, with a realization that both the RC and Mennonite communities were already engaged in many similar Christian social ministries, such as services for immigrants and refugees, as well as prison-ministry and restorative justice. This offered an opportunity for deliberate working together, enhanced mutual understanding, and meaningful togetherness in Christ. By way of encouragement, a similar group already existed in Winnipeg, plus we had the example of the Bridgefolk, uniting “sacramentally-minded Mennonites with peace-minded Catholics.” Thus a group started in Edmonton; it was small, a mere eleven people, but two key individuals were the pastor of Lendrum Mennonite Brethren church and the outreach officer of the RC Archdiocese of Edmonton.
The initial plan was to have a series of meetings, studying together “Called Together to be Peacemakers,” a 2003 report from the international dialogue between Mennonite World Conference and the Roman Catholic Church. Despite its visionary title, we quickly found that before meaningful discussion could occur, we needed to establish mutual trust and respect. To achieve this, each person in the group shared their personal faith story, warts and all – typically one Mennonite and one RC per meeting. That format seemed to work well, and led to a larger gathering of about 50 invited people, sharing frankly “what does it mean to be a Roman Catholic or a Mennonite?” The over-arching image was that our denominations are all part of the broader Christian family: while we might have disagreements, we still belong to each other.
Subsequent years saw a gradual growth in numbers involved, presentations by researchers and scholars that led to fruitful discussions, and a deeper understanding and appreciation for “the other” and the ways they expressed their desire to follow Jesus faithfully. One “discovery” was that both traditions (at least nowadays) place great emphasis on study and application of the Scripture, such that there is far more convergence than divergence. Meetings continued regularly, sometimes using a book as a study guide, sometimes discussing a “safe” topic, such as Care for the Environment, or confronting Racism. Other topics have been more awkward or potentially divisive, such as Reconciliation with First Nations, Baptism, the Sacraments, or power within the Church. An exploration of martyrdom – when the martyrs were made such by religious authorities! – exposed more common ground than might have been expected. During these years there has been a growing sense that we all have gifts, and that sharing these gifts widely benefits the whole body of Christ.
The long shadow of Vatican II surely helped establish a willingness – even an eagerness – for RCs to interact more with other Christian groups. Meanwhile, the irenic pronouncements and actions of Pope Francis encouraged rapprochement from Mennonites. Over the years, some members of our growing group attended Bridgefolk conferences, and the wider Christian community has been occasionally involved through “open” meetings, such as a joyful hymn-sing or public lecture. The year 2025 marked the quincentenary of the founding of Anabaptism in Zürich, Switzerland. The early years were difficult and Anabaptists endured much persecution, but at the end of May 2025 in the Grossmünster of Zürich there was a profoundly meaningful service of remembrance, thankfulness, and reconciliation, in which leaders of the Reformed and Mennonite churches apologized for their history of conflict, and committed to reconciliation and working together for the future. At the same service, Pope Leo XIV sent a letter equally seeking reconciliation and an end to centuries of mistrust and animosity.
So the world has changed. There seems to be far less suspicion between denominations, far more openness to dialogue with erst-while “enemies.” Pope Francis’ successor is eager to build on his predecessor’s foundations, and the Mennonites among us are thrilled to hear his anti-war pronouncements. At the same time, in the outside world, traditional friendships and alliances have been shattered, governments appear ever more eager to sell arms and encourage violent conflict rather than seek peace and justice, while within the church some sectors seem to have strayed from Jesus’ command to love our enemies, becoming increasingly strident and even oppressive of anyone with whom they disagree. The result: Roman Catholics and Mennonites often find themselves in the same corner with the same concerns and outlooks. We are now wondering “where next?”